1. How do you classify this paper (Overall)

Strong Reject
Weak Reject
Neutral
Weak Accept
Strong Accept


2. Reviewer''s confidence

High
Medium
Low



3. What problem, issue, or question does this research address?


4. What is the significance of this problem, issue, or question?


5. Do the authors clearly describe the problem they are intending to solve? 
Do they motivate the significance and impact of this problem
in a broader context?


6. What is the proposal (i.e., what experiments, prototypes, or studies will be done to achieve the stated goal)? Is it clearly defined and described?


7. How will the achievement or contribution of the research be demonstrated or validated?


8. How much progress has been made, and what are the current challenges presented to the research student?

9. Does the paper provide a comprehensive overview of the current state of the art in the addressed research field? Do the authors compare their approach to existing ones?

10. Originality



11. Significance / usefulness




12. Technical Soundness




13. References




14. Presentation




15. Should the paper be considered for the best paper award?



16. Detailed comments to the author(s). Please elaborate on your rankings above and provide concrete feedback to the authors to improve their paper.