Will the EU decide to double up?

A plan to combine the two eurozone bailout funds will be on the table at a meeting in Copenhagen this week. Ben Chu explains why

Two European bailout funds would be better than one. That's the view of many observers of the long-running eurozone sovereign debt crisis. And that's the reason pressure is rising for European finance ministers to "double up" when the meet in the Danish capital, Copenhagen, on Friday.

Here's how the plan would work: the temporary European Financial Stability Fund (EFSF), which has a €440bn (£388bn) lending capacity, is due to expire in June 2013. It is due to be replaced by a permanent European Stability Mechanism (ESM), with a lending capacity of €500bn, this summer. European leaders agreed to bring forward the establishment of the permanent fund last year in one of their many bids to calm the frenzied financial markets. So the new plan would be to keep the temporary fund in operation after this summer has passed and to run the two bailout pots in tandem. This would give the European bailout funds a combined firepower of €940bn.

That would then open the door for members of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) – who have made it clear that they will only increase their resources when the EU gets its own house in order – to boost the multilateral lender's lending power to €1trn. This would give investors the reassurance of total bailout resources to help prop up the eurozone of close to €2trn, unlocking confidence and investment.

So what's the obstacle? There are two. The first is politics. Germany, the country which is on the hook for the largest portion of both the bailout funds, has been resistant to the idea of running the two pots of money in parallel, because that would, inevitably, extend the scale of its own national guarantees to its southern European neighbours.

Berlin has, in fairness, given some ground on this. The German Chancellor, Angela Merkel, tested the water this weekend with a proposal for two funds to run in tandem only until the middle of next year. Ms Merkel is said to have calculated this is the maximum she could get past her parliament.

But it is not clear that such a time-limited plan would unlock the extra IMF resources. Other IMF members, particularly the US, might well judge that Europe is still not doing enough to warrant them increasing their own commitments to the multinational rescue fund.

That feeds in to the second obstacle: market credibility. A time limit on the tandem operation could be self-defeating. Many investors say they want to know that the eurozone, in co-operation with the IMF, has sufficient resources on hand to prevent member states the size of Spain and Italy from defaulting on their debts. The two countries between them make up more than 35 per cent of the eurozone bond market. The combined bailout fund would only just cover their financing needs over the coming years. Indeed, it might be too small. With €200bn committed from the EFSF to Greece, Ireland and Portugal, the true size of the combined funds would be €740bn rather than €940bn. Further, the ESM would revert back to €500bn in size in the summer of 2013. Investors, it is said, are looking for much longer-term security than that.

Or are they? The financial markets have actually been much calmer in recent weeks since the Greek bailout was agreed. The injection of around €1trn into the European banking system by the European Central Bank in recent months has successfully dispelled fears of an imminent major European financial crisis. Banks now have enough money to see them through the next three years.

This has fed through to greater confidence in sovereign debt. The 10-year borrowing costs of Italy and Spain have fallen dramatically from their peaks last November which were above 7 and 6 per cent respectively.

But some feel this central bank activism has resulted in dangerous complacency among politicians.

"The rally stems from a sense of relief more than anything else" said Nicholas Spiro of Spiro Sovereign Strategy. "The pendulum of sentiment has swung from paranoia to sanguinity bordering on complacency in the space of just four or five weeks."

Yet markets might be turning again. Spain's 10-year borrowing costs crept back up above 5.4 per cent last week as investors began to cotton on to the fact that its economy is shrinking and the centre-right government in Madrid is struggling to bring down the deficit.

Progress on Friday could be elusive because there is disagreement about what is concerning bond market investors. The European Commission's top economic official, Olli Rehn, said at the weekend that investors in Spanish debt are primarily concerned about slippage by the Spanish government on deficit reduction.

"Because there was a perception Spain was relaxing its fiscal targets for this year, there has already been a market reaction of several dozen basis points on yields of Spanish bonds," he told reporters at an informal gathering of European leaders in Finland.

Yet some analysts claim that the concern of investors is precisely the opposite: that austerity, demanded by the EU, is driving the Spanish economy further into the mire and making the need for a rescue (which the EU might not be able to afford) more likely.

"Spain is on the sharp end of the anxiety because of growing fears that its austerity drive has become self-defeating," said Mr Spiro.

Given all that, what should we expect from Copenhagen? Throughout this crisis, European leaders have done the minimum possible at every stage in the hope that it would prove enough. A combination of the two rescue funds is likely; a permanent bolstering of the eurozone's firewall is not.

Independent Comment
blog comments powered by Disqus
Career Services

Day In a Page

The 50 Best beachwear

The 50 Best beachwear

The hottest summer gear for men and women
Still standing: George Galloway reveals why his staunchly Leftist outlook is still invariably right

Still standing: George Galloway

Written off, ridiculed, wrongly accused of taking bribes the honourable member for Bradford West, has never bowed to the critics.
How will Daniel Radcliffe's fans react to his latest turn - as a damaged, drug-taking Beatnik poet?

Daniel Radcliffe as drug-taking Beatnik poet

His decade as the boy wizard may be over, but that hasn't hexed Daniel Radcliffe's enchanted life.
For whom the bell tolls: £20m 'Memo' project takes shape on Dorset's Jurassic coast

'Memo' project takes shape on Dorset coast

It started as a stonemason's visionary idea – to commemorate all the species that have ever existed and are now extinct.
Just add sunshine: Bill Granger's Turkish delights

Just add sunshine: Bill Granger's Turkish delights

Turkish cuisine is perfect for those long, sociable weekend meals with friends. It's just a shame that money can't buy the key ingredient.
Objets czar: David Usborne’s collection of myriad objects is quite the mystery

Objets czar: David Usborne’s collection of myriad objects

To others, they're junk. To David Usborne, they are his life: useful gizmos, mysterious thingamajigs and anonymous articles that dominate his home.
The iron ore lady: Why the world's richest woman is mired in controversy

World's richest woman: Gina Rinehart

Family feuds, attempts to control the Australian media and bitter public disputes are keeping the mining magnate in the headlines.
We just click: How Lego keeps building on its success

How Lego keeps building on its success

This year, Lego announced record profits. Gerard Gilbert visits its Denmark HQ.
The other bits: Mark Hix creates delicious and economical meals with cheaper cuts of meat

Mark Hix cooks with cheaper cuts of meat

Our chef creates delicious and economical meals on a budget
Strokes of genius: How to create summer's bold make-up look

Strokes of genius: Summer's bold make-up

From coral lips to fly-away fringes, make-up artist Kim Brown and hair stylist Richard Scorer reveal how to create the look
Marking his territory: Kilian Hennessy creates fragrances designed to provoke the senses

Marking his territory: Kilian Hennessy

The perfumer creates fragrances designed to provoke the senses
Photo essay: Britain's 1948 Olympians today

Britain's 1948 Olympians today

Photo essay
The top five E3 2012 triumphs: From Ubisoft's suite of titles to Dishonored and The Last of Us

The top five E3 2012 triumphs

The games and moments that left us grinning like the Cheshire Cat
The green movement at 50: Can the world be saved?

Can the world be saved?

Population growth and climate change are the big problems facing the earth in the next 50 years. But are there any solutions?
France: Will xenophobia go mainstream?

France: Will xenophobia go mainstream?

In the beautiful Rhone delta, John Lichfield visits a village where a dangerous new political landscape is taking shape